Answer 2:
Keep on thinking because I don't think anyone
really knows the answer! But I'll try to
explain the little bit I understand with an
example:
Suppose my friend Jon tossed an
egg across the room and I catch it. Now
suppose we used a video camera to film the egg fly
out of Jon's hand, across the room, and into
Mark's hand. Play the video
frame-by-frame. We stop at a frame where the
egg is halfway across the room. That camera has
recorded the position-in-space of the egg at that
position-in-time. When I
say "position-in-space," I don't mean where
astronauts go. I mean, "the egg is 3.1 meters off
the ground, and 4.7 meters in front of Jon's
hand." When I say "position-in-time", I
mean,"0.2 seconds after the egg has left Jon's
hand." What units is "position-in-space"
measured in? What units is "position-in-time"
measured in?
Now suppose you didn't know
what happened, and you were looking at the video
for the very first time. Now I have the remote
control for the VCR, so you don't know that I have
pushed "reverse." You see the egg flying from
Mark to Jon, instead of from Jon to
Mark.
Which possibility can you correctly
conclude?
A. The egg goes from Mark to Jon, and
the VCR is playing forward.
B. The egg goes
from Jon to Mark, and the VCR is playing
backward.
C. You cannot conclude A or B.
In this case, the correct answer is
C.
Does this mean that the only difference
between "position-in-time" and
"position-in-space" are the units in which we
measure those quantities?,
Now suppose that I
was a klutz, and instead of catching the egg, it
broke in my hand. Again, you see the tape played
in reverse, but you don't know that I pushed
reverse.
Which possibility can you correctly
conclude?
A. A hundred pieces of egg-shell and
dripping yolk spontaneously merged to form a whole
egg. The VCR is playing forward.
B. The whole
egg landed in my hand and broke into a hundred
pieces of egg-shell and dripping yolk. The VCR is
playing backwards.
C. You cannot conclude A or B.
Of, course, B is correct. An smashed egg
cannot spontaneously become whole again.
What is going on here? It seems that Time
has an ARROW. It goes FORWARD. But why does
the breaking egg only make sense breaking apart
instead of coming together, while the flying egg
makes sense going either left or
right?
Physicists are trying to understand
Time by asking these and similar questions.
They
take an event (sort of like our egg toss, except
they use microscopic particles) and ask, Which
possibility can we conclude?
A. The event occurred as we see it and time is
playing forward.
B. We are viewing the mirror-image of
the event with all the chargesreversed, and
time is playing backward.
C. We cannot conclude A or B.
Remember, keep thinking about this
because nobody really understands it, especially
me! |